The man at the bar tells you the Grand National is a lottery. Stick a pin in the paper, pick the grey, back the one with the funny name. He says it every April. Look at the recent winners, though, and a pattern shows through: they tend to be a similar age, carry a similar weight, enjoy a bit of cut in the ground and, increasingly, arrive from the same Irish gallops. Picking a Grand National winner is not about finding a magic horse. It is about narrowing a 40-runner field to the few that fit the profile.
How do you pick a Grand National winner? Narrow the field in steps. Set aside horses aged 12 or older and those likely to go off at 60.0 or longer, because neither group has produced a winner in the nine runnings from 2016 to 2025. (The price finding uses Betfair SP, the exchange’s closing price, so on the day treat the market price as a guide.) Then favour 8 and 9 year olds carrying roughly 11st 0lb to 11st 8lb, with a run in the last 31 to 60 days, ideally trained in Ireland. That leaves four or five horses worth a proper look. It is a snapshot of nine runnings, so treat it as a strong lead rather than a rule.
Why is the Grand National not a lottery?
A 40-runner handicap over four and a quarter miles with thirty fences sounds like chaos. In Race Advisor’s look at the 2016 to 2025 Grand Nationals, though, the winning profile is narrower than the lottery story suggests. A handicap is a race where the weights are set by an official handicapper to give every runner a chance, and the National still tends to reward particular ages, weight bands, yards and price ranges.
The overall A/E for the National over that period was 0.96 at Betfair SP. A/E is actual winners divided by the winners the odds implied, so a figure close to 1.00 says the market prices the field about right. That is useful to know. The profile is not a promise of a hidden edge. It is a way to organise your reading: narrow the field to the segment that has been winning, then read those horses closely.
Which ages suit the Grand National?
Age is the easiest cut. The older view was that 8 year olds were too inexperienced and 7 year olds could not win. The recent runnings point the other way: 8 year olds produced five winners from 78 runners (6.4%), and adding the one 7 year old winner means six of the nine winners came from an age band that made up only 104 of the 348 runners.
At the other end, horses aged 12 or older ran 26 times in those nine runnings without a winner. Across UK handicap chases of three miles or more with sixteen or more runners, 12 year olds win at 0.7%, against more than 5% for 5 to 8 year olds. Stamina over marathon trips tends to fade with age.
So the age rule is simple. Set aside the 12 year olds and over, lean towards 8 and 9 year olds, and treat 10 and 11 year olds as live but not preferred.
What weight should you look for?
The old wisdom was to stick to horses carrying 10st 5lb to 11st. The recent runnings suggest the slightly higher middle weights deserve more attention. The 10st 5lb to 11st band was the biggest group by far, with 217 runners and a 2.3% win rate. The 11st 5lb to 11st 8lb band, a much smaller group, supplied three of the nine winners. That is a small sample, so it is a lead rather than a rule, but it points to a sweet spot.
The literal top weight (the horse the BHA rates highest) has run nine times in these years without winning. The horses rated second or third highest supplied two winners. The idea is that top weight carries the biggest burden, while the band just behind it is where serious stamina-and-class horses sit.
A usable weight rule: set aside the literal top weight, keep everything from about 11st 0lb to 11st 8lb in your shortlist, and only drop to the lighter end if a specific horse has a clear stamina or trainer reason to be there.
How much does the going matter?
Aintree on National day has been Good to Soft or softer in eight of the last nine years, so the race tends to be a stamina test and the winners typically have proven form in cut ground.
Going is best used as a confirmation on the day rather than a hard filter, because the ground is what it is. If the official going is Good to Soft or softer, lean harder into horses with previous wins on Soft or Heavy. If the ground has dried out unexpectedly, give more credit to horses that handled better ground, such as at the recent Cheltenham Festival.
Why does Irish form deserve attention?
The 2013 Race Advisor guide pointed to different trainers, and the picture has moved on. In recent years most of the winners have been trained in Ireland, by yards that target the race seriously. They route horses through specific prep races, such as the Bobbyjo Chase and the Boyne Hurdle, and arrive at Aintree on a plan, which is a plausible reason for the pattern and a useful tiebreaker.
When two horses look equal on form, a horse from a yard with a clear National programme is worth the extra look.
Which prices give you the best starting point?
Four of the nine winners went off between 8.0 and 16.0 on Betfair SP, so that range is a good place to focus once your shortlist is built. Horses priced 60.0 or longer have not produced a winner since 2016 (169 runners), so the very top of the price range is the easiest group to set aside.
That does not mean back the favourite blindly. The Betfair SP favourite won twice in nine, a 22.2% rate, which is respectable. The sensible order is to build the shortlist on age, weight and stable first, then look at the horses on it that fall inside the 8.0 to 16.0 range.
How do you build a shortlist instead of a single pick?
The aim is to walk in with four or five live horses rather than one. You can back them each way (a bet on the horse to win or place) or dutch the win side, which means splitting your stake across several horses so each returns about the same if it wins.
Walk it through on a real card:
- Start with all 40 names.
- Set aside the 12 year olds and over.
- Set aside horses priced 60.0 or longer on Betfair.
- Prefer a run in the last 31 to 60 days.
- From the survivors, favour 8 and 9 year olds carrying 11st 0lb to 11st 8lb, ideally Irish-trained.
- Use PR Rank, Race Advisor’s own ordering of the field, to choose between the survivors, and give extra attention to horses in its top four.
You will land on four or five live runners, and that is your shortlist.
What is the takeaway?
The Grand National is not a lottery. It is a handicap with a recognisable winning profile, and you can use that profile to spend your attention on the horses that fit it. Narrow by age and price, favour the middle to upper weights, give Irish prep form a close look, and you finish with a handful of horses with a real chance rather than one with a romantic name.
This is a way to read the race, not a proven system: nine runnings is a snapshot, and a broader test would be needed to call it more. Keep a record of how your shortlist performs year to year, because every new National adds to the picture. To try the same filters on any race, open today’s race cards and sort the field by PR Rank.



